Jump to content
BIG KAHUNA CHARITY PUNTERS CLUB CONTINUES THIS SATURDAY

Lloyd Vivian

Members
  • Posts

    2,899
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    14

Everything posted by Lloyd Vivian

  1. He'll be the first since Coup Align was a baby!!!! - but you're entitled to your opinion. Cheers!!
  2. Yes Franky - it COULD be misleading] something a bit special b] or a 'fluke' due to extenuating circumstances. I think in CA's case we can agree that his 1:07 was not a b] as he has gone to bigger and better things and as I've said, recorded three exceptionally fast times over 1000m also. Anyway, you sucked me back into this one again but I promise I'll leave it after this as I suggested last time and we'll wait and see aye?. Cheers!
  3. Not another year - just a dry track. Perhaps we'd better agree to differ about him until he proves himself one way or the other on the track. Cheers.
  4. Franky I credited you with being a better judge... So of all the 1200m races at Riccarton [where it is apparently so easy to reel off a 1.07 time] last season, how many horses actually did it? My guess would be you'd only need one hand to tally them up..and by your own admission only the 'best horses' would be capable of it anyway right??? Which is exactly what I've been saying.... I would doubt very much that Coup Align would come all the way to Te Rapa for a 1400m race Frank. He is probably the fastest 1000m - 1200m horse in the country [only Mufhasa of those currently racing, spring to mind as a real opponent over 1200m] and I certainly don't see him as a danger in a 1400m race at the top level, although he has stretched to 1355m in lesser company. But SO WHAT? Does that make him any less of a sprinter over 1000 -1200m? Plenty of top Ozzie sprinters only run the 1200m trip - [ie Gold Trail for one] - and I certainly haven't been talking CA up as anything other than a freak over the short-course distances. 1400m and 1600m are not a true sprint distance. Look around the world and you'll see the best G1 sprints are 1200m or less and run at the time of year when good going is expected. So your point about him being only average because he wouldn't win the Stradbroke is completely spurious. ALL the best sprinters need a fast track to show their best and run a really fast time - why is that a negative in CA's case? THe Telegraph's winning time this year was SLOW Franky, for a Telegraph especially. Victory Dias and Seachange would have been nearly 15 lengths in front by comparison. Vonusti just LOVED the going and got the lollies. If it's soft at Te Rapa he could win that too - [he'll run about 1.22 which is what he's shown he's capable of to date] and if he goes to the Stradbroke and strikes a similar track he could do it again - but does that mean he's faster than Coup Align over 1200m on a fast track??? Of course not. My point is still valid Franky; Coup Align is arguably the fastest horse in NZ over 1200m and it's a crying shame that rain and a mug track doctor combined to foil his crack at the 'big time'. I just hope he gets another chance to do it.
  5. My point was that to say 1.07 for 1200m is nothing to write home about is plain crazy! Start a list Franky, of all the horses that did it last year for a start - anywhere!! Tell me when you need more postage stamps...
  6. You talkin' crazy Frankee! I KNOW you not really that silly....
  7. Hi Nahla I have never said at any stage that the three horses you mention were not capable of running 1.07 - I simply pointed out that on the day, only two had done it up till that point. And really, the whole point of my argument is that the soft track effectively stopped ANY horse running 1.07 or anything near it!!! THAT is what I'm upset about! It was a NON-EVENT in determinig who's the fastest horse in the country, and that was disappointing. I don't think for one minute that Vonusti is a slug] to show their best. We won't know now, how he compared against Gold Trail for example ; he never went a yard in it and finished last. Did that make him the slowest horse in the field? Doubt it! Likewise; I would have loved to see how CA went head to head against Mufhasa on ground that suited them both. He finished in front of him on a soft track - but could he do that on a fast track? We'll never know. Anyway, I remain firmly of the opinion that CA is absolutely top class because it doesn't matter where you run 55.6 for 1000m, or 1.07 for 1200m; if you can do it at all you are pretty special! I just hope he gets a chance to really prove himself against the best at some stage. All I say in response to your question about Sprinter of the Year is this: he has been undefeated up to 1300m on good tracks apart from two early runs as a 2yo. Two jockeys have commented that he is probably the fastest horse they've ever sat on. He has run times VERY few are capable of over sprint distances. Personally, I think on a hard track, based on how he performed on an unsuitable soft track, he must have gone extremely close to winning the Telegraph against an awesome field. Had he won - I would have had him Sprinter of the Year. As it is, his chance has gone for this season, I'd say.
  8. Yep - usually by this time it is fairly obvious that a foal will be grey. Hope it turns out a nice horse for you.
  9. Well said Centrofold. There were only two horses in that field that have run 1.07 for 1200m [Mufhasa and Coup Align for the record], and they finished side by side in 6th & 7th place. I was anticipating the clash between them and the Aussies on a fast track for weeks! As it turned out it was simply not a true indication of sprinting ability due to the track. The opportunity to rate our best against some half-decent Aussie sprinters on our own turf won't happen again in a hurry - which only adds to the 'aaaaggh' factor! and Darryl - ask Sticko if he thinks Vonusti would blow Mufhasa away on a good track like he did on Saturday!
  10. I'm no bookie [and yes, OK, that was an exaggeration to make a point ] - but it would depend of course on the two horses and the distance: what would you offer if it was Sunline and Bonecrusher over 1200m???? I'm not trying to knock Vonusti - he's a real good horse and NGH is one of my favourite jockeys [although he probably isn't Jeff Lynd's at the moment!!!] - but for you to say he's "a far superior horse to Coup Align over 1200m on good tracks" is clearly your personal like for the horse getting in the way of the facts.
  11. Surely YOU jest???!!! Vonusti: 3 wins @ 1200m. Fastest time 1.09.3[yesterday] 1 win over 1000m time: 1.00.77 Coup Align: 3 wins @ 1200 [and 1 @ 1250m] fastest time 1.07.7 3 wins over 1000m] but 1:09.3 is a long way off the Telegraph record. He is not the short course sprinter that Coup Align is and never will be. Neither will Coup Align be the 1400m -1600m horse that Vonusti is either. However, the Telegraph is not the Thorndon; it's supposed to be the toughest test of our best sprinters over 1200m. It just disappoints me that he and a few others never got their chance to really 'strut their stuff' on a hard track which you reasonably expect in late January. If it was just rain you shrug your shoulders - but when irrigation is added to the mix unneccesarily, it is worse! So all credit to Team Carter, Harris and Vonusti - but please no more talk that he is a superior 1200m horse to Coup Align on good tracks!
  12. Run the race again on a hard track and Coup Align would be paying $1.50 and Vonusti $10 - even in a match race! You can't tell me that tne winning trio comprise the three fastest sprinters in NZ at the moment!!! You HAVE to be joking. The wet track was the ruination of a fantastic race and the winning time reflects that. Nearly three seconds off the race record - that's fifteen lengths.
  13. With all best wishes, congratulations and respect to the connections of Vonusti, Tootsie and Stupendous - but this race was a travesty of justice! Coup Align kicked the winner's brains in at Riccarton carrying the grandstand on a hard track...how brave he was today!
  14. Exactly Leigh - drives a lot of us mad! What a spectacle the Telegraph was shaping up to be - and now it's quite simply been downgraded; sure the rain may have done that anyway - but why exacerbate it with irrigation??????
  15. What a let-down! A slow 7 for the race of the year...Coup Align will still battle on through it, but no chance to show his best. Nor many of the other REAL sprinters. Why MUST they add water when so much rain is around???
  16. Nah mate - a wet track brings Atapi right into it!
  17. I don't see why if you look at Coup Align's record and manner of wins that anyone could think he's "out of his depth." Mike Pitman is no mug trainer and he thinks Coup Align is something real special too! David Walsh who has won on the horse gave him a real 'wrap' in yesterday's paper too. Make no mistake - if they don't completely stuff the track with their watering overnight he's right in this race on 52.5kgs! I think Gold Trail willl fold in the last 100 or so in this race. He got a relatively 'easy' win in the Railway through dictating the pace - but this race will be run in a world record over 1200m - not 1100 - and I think he'll be swamped late. Portelli has been talking him up in the press but he did say on arrival in NZ that the horse was really an 1100m horse and needed things go his way to win over 1200m. None of us know just how good Wealth Princess is yet - she sure LOOKS awesome at this point, and may look even more sensational after the race - but in my opinion, Coup Align is probably the fastest 1200m horse in NZ at present. It IS his biggest test - but don't discount him - he's a tough, freakishly fast sprinter! Mufhasa COULD slingshot them at his best - as could Wall Street and Tavistock; and Coup Align and Gold Trail between them could set it up perfectly for any of those three and W.P to do just that. But boy! they will have to run a record to do it I reckon. And I know of those two expected leaders, who I'd be expecting to get 'the stitch' at the 100m mark - and it aint Coup Align!!
  18. If the rains come- watch out for Court Ruler!!
  19. I'm with you Zimmo - I think Coup Align is freakishly fast. His times running against himself - all opposition to date no help! - have been spectacular. However, my only concern is that he sets it up perfectly for something to slingshot him in the last 50. Can't see him not being in the first 3.
  20. Yes sorry - you're exactly right! I WAS confusing those two and Danske has certainly gone on to more than useful as a sire. Cheers. My comments are rescinded.
  21. Jeff stood the horse originally. He always appealed to me on type and sire, but his stock probably don't go quick enough early enough to be a commercial prospect. It's pretty hard to 'make' a CD horse at stud unless they are truly outstanding. I wish Jeff every success - he's been in the game a long time and had his share of average ones..
  22. I agree Zimmo; those two are clearly the two to beat at Trentham and while I missed her race yesterday Wealth Princess is obviously very special. I'd love to see her do well at the top level - no-one loves a good horse more than me - but the two aforementioned are two big obstacles for my money.
  23. She is obviously hugely talented - no question about that. HOWEVER....I think some of us have forgotten just how good the big black galloping machine from Ardmore is!!! Watch the Telegraph tape again guys....you're trying to say a 3 win horse will blow away our current Horse of the Year fresh up over 1200m??? BIG CALL!!!! That's all I say....
×
×
  • Create New...

While the owners and managers of RaceCafe endeavour to moderate and control the site and posts on it, they give no guarantee that posts are true and correct, and take no responsibility whatsoever for what individuals post on the site.

Posts do not necessarily reflect the sentiments, views or beliefs of Race Cafe or its owners and management.

The owners and managers of RaceCafe reserve the right to remove posts from the site and to provide details of members whose posts warrant scrutiny.