Jump to content
More Members. More Posts. More Racing

Recommended Posts

Posted
46 minutes ago, Farnarkler said:

Despite the slaughter of a ride by Zac Proxima Dea wins the OAKS. 

Seldom do you see a 3 yo filly, or colt for that matter overcome a ride like that, absolutely marvellous...

Yeap ridden to be beaten, but so gutsy on her part, thought the run of Quynh the David an Emma Browne was super as well, think she ended up 5th but deserved to be closer, held up a couple of times looking for a run, probably cost her 4th, not bad from 150$ shot, pleased for them being ex kiwi trainers.

Posted
21 minutes ago, Shad said:

Yeap ridden to be beaten, but so gutsy on her part, thought the run of Quynh the David an Emma Browne was super as well, think she ended up 5th but deserved to be closer, held up a couple of times looking for a run, probably cost her 4th, not bad from 150$ shot, pleased for them being ex kiwi trainers.

Can you help me pronounce that name, please? No, not David or Emma or even Browne...

Posted
1 hour ago, Farnarkler said:

Despite the slaughter of a ride by Zac Proxima Dea wins the OAKS. 

Seldom do you see a 3 yo filly, or colt for that matter overcome a ride like that, absolutely marvellous...

Looked a poor ride but I think he just rode her to be the best stayer , and she was .

She has a phenomenal depth of stamina .

Melbourne Cup next year , here we come .

Posted
1 hour ago, say no more said:

Great young jockey with a fantastic strike rate.  Not his best ride but harsh to say he slaughtered it.  
 

Drew wide so was never going to get an easy trail, but knew he was on the best horse so just kept it balanced at a steady pace and in clear running.

 

 

 

 

100% agree he gave her an uninterrupted run, and he explained his thoughts clearly after the race, great young rider, nowhere near a slaughter.

Posted
8 hours ago, nomates said:

Looked a poor ride but I think he just rode her to be the best stayer , and she was .

She has a phenomenal depth of stamina .

Melbourne Cup next year , here we come .

mate I hope they don't target the Cup next year. If memory serves only Light Fingers has done it 1964 Oaks to 1965 Cup. Plenty of rich  races for PD without being tested over 3200m as 4 year-old. Fraught with danger.

Posted
2 hours ago, Maximus said:

mate I hope they don't target the Cup next year. If memory serves only Light Fingers has done it 1964 Oaks to 1965 Cup. Plenty of rich  races for PD without being tested over 3200m as 4 year-old. Fraught with danger.

Ethereal , Let's Elope .

PD is made for the Cup .

Posted
10 hours ago, scooby3051 said:

100% agree he gave her an uninterrupted run, and he explained his thoughts clearly after the race, great young rider, nowhere near a slaughter.

You know better than that, plaudits when they're due, and he can ride the fella, but that was poor by his standards. 3 wide over a hard Flemington 2500, you either go back or forward from that gate, he jumped well and she's proved she can race handy, even outside the leader, but to just sit there, Jesus, that filly is really special.

Posted
11 minutes ago, Farnarkler said:

You know better than that, plaudits when they're due, and he can ride the fella, but that was poor by his standards. 3 wide over a hard Flemington 2500, you either go back or forward from that gate, he jumped well and she's proved she can race handy, even outside the leader, but to just sit there, Jesus, that filly is really special.

Really? You think he would have used less energy pressing forward or dragging back than staying put relaxed and breathing? Watch the top European riders. American ones too.

Posted
7 minutes ago, Leggy said:

Really? You think he would have used less energy pressing forward or dragging back than staying put relaxed and breathing? Watch the top European riders. American ones too.

You don't have to push forward, she's a free goer she would have got there herself, Payne admitted himself he was worried, and being an ex champion jockey he was entitled to be, also if you watch her earlier runs she got back and settled, you don't have to drag her back, if you want to compere our racing with European racing you need help.......and as for the yanks, the tempo in US racing is,........flat out!.......only the strong survive.

One of the best horses I've ever seen was Skip Away, he won the Don Hcp at Gulfstream G1 first up running the first half mile of the 1900m in 44sec, Hello? and dirt racing is vastly different to grass, they sit wide to avoid the kick back, you should know that being an expert on the USA.....

Posted

“She jumped really well, and there was a bit of jostling for a spot early, and I didn’t want to be the one working into that bend.

“I came out of the speed, knowing that I might get caught wide, but I was hoping the speed would increase down the side and I’d have my chance to get in. I had to take what I was given and trust I was on the best stayer on the day, and that she was.

“Although I was wide, we weren’t going quick and I was in a straight line, so I just focused on her. She was in a lovely rhythm. She was very ready for me today, and David’s training was fantastic. She was fresh enough, but she was still able to stay as she did.

Posted
12 minutes ago, Maximus said:

come on, nm ..Ethereal won a Queensland Oaks (2200m) not a VRC Oaks (2500m)...and Let's Elope didn't win an Oaks.

I don't get your argument .

PD is unbeaten in 6 , just won the Spring Champion Stakes in Sydney then the VRC Oaks , the first filly to ever do that , THE FIRST !!!!

In the Spring Champion Stakes she beat the subsequent impressive VRC Derby winner .

She's bred to stay , and she stays better than even those you have just listed .

Her trainer David Payne , a shrewd trainer said himself he has always wanted to win a Melbourne Cup and he finally has a horse that could do it .

Running in the MC next year is not fraught with danger , it's what she was built for .

I might even suggest she could win the AJC Derby in the Autumn , if not the AJC double .

Posted

No doubt she's all class, nm, and a genuine stayer. Not knocking the ambition, but they've hardly had time to put an Oaks trophy on the mantelpiece and it's 'Melbourne Cup, here we come'.?
My argument is "too far too soon". What's the rush?  Some classy Spring 3yos don't go on with it through the autumn or the next year and get 'issues'...TreasuredaMoment is a recent one that comes to mind.
Very exciting opportunities ahead for her connections.

Posted
1 hour ago, Alf Riston said:

Zardozi was a recent Oaks winner that went on to run a really solid Melbourne Cup as a 4yo.

Looked the winner, but didn't quite carry it out 🥲 

 

1 hour ago, Alf Riston said:

Zardozi was a recent Oaks winner that went on to run a really solid Melbourne Cup as a 4yo.

Looked the winner, but didn't quite carry it out 🥲 

indeed...some creditable runs after the Oaks, notably that 4th at Flemo
but after her 3yo VRC Spring heroics she won only once more (fresh-up 1500m Phar Lap Stakes, Sydney in the autumn) and never won a race as a 4yo or 5yo mare - including a crack at a 3200m race (Sydney Cup).
..not saying Proxima Dea can't win a Melbourne Cup...maybe she's The Next Goddess (after Winx) ...just got my fingers crossed they exercise some caution on the 3200m race(s).

Posted
3 minutes ago, Maximus said:

 

indeed...some creditable runs after the Oaks, notably that 4th at Flemo
but after her 3yo VRC Spring heroics she won only once more (fresh-up 1500m Phar Lap Stakes, Sydney in the autumn) and never won a race as a 4yo or 5yo mare - including a crack at a 3200m race (Sydney Cup).
..not saying Proxima Dea can't win a Melbourne Cup...maybe she's The Next Goddess (after Winx) ...just got my fingers crossed they exercise some caution on the 3200m race(s).

Pretty much spot on Max - never quite delivered after the convincing Oaks win.

Might leave something special though I'd pick.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

While the owners and managers of RaceCafe endeavour to moderate and control the site and posts on it, they give no guarantee that posts are true and correct, and take no responsibility whatsoever for what individuals post on the site.

Posts do not necessarily reflect the sentiments, views or beliefs of Race Cafe or its owners and management.

The owners and managers of RaceCafe reserve the right to remove posts from the site and to provide details of members whose posts warrant scrutiny.