Scotch Thistle

Members
  • Content count

    218
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Scotch Thistle last won the day on September 4 2016

Scotch Thistle had the most liked content!

About Scotch Thistle

  • Rank
    Maiden - R50

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Scotch Thistle

    Te Rapa Track...Is it worth the money they spent on it???

    Having listened through the interview, I'm encouraged by Rutherford's recognition and admission of the mess Te Rapa is in and the earnest response needed to get things back in order. This response seems to include flicking off two industry meetings in September to other tracks, and undersewing grass, but meantime having plenty of hooves help to force that sand from the surface into the ground. A question Coppins (useless interviewer) didn't ask Rutherford is why the club didn't have anyone competent overseeing the work done in February. Rutherford said the contractor did a "very shoddy job", being supposed to spread 4-6 mm depth of sand across the course, but actually putting on up to 2 inches (i.e. 50mm) in places in a central strip of the track. 50mm is 8 to 12 times the depth of sand supposed to have been laid, so it was indeed a shoddy job. Clearly the club was incompetent in not noticing and intervening whilst the contractor's shoddy work was in progress. Follow-up questions Coppins might have asked are whether Te Rapa paid the contractor, is seeking compensation, and has warned other clubs off using the shoddy outfit.
  2. Scotch Thistle

    Surely Not! Must be a doppelgänger.

    Our Glenda certainly spreads far and wide. I hadn't caught up with her going transsexual, a prerequisite if she/he is to be a doyen of anything.
  3. Scotch Thistle

    Apprentice caught Punting

    I reckon you'll find out how he was potted if you read the article you've quoted. Read it carefully, top to bottom and left to right, and you might surprise yourself as to how clever you are
  4. Scotch Thistle

    Saundry on AW tracks

    Yet another one is that were Awapuni, say, to have a synthetic track installed inside the grass one, and both were usable, who makes the call as to which the transferred meeting is raced on?
  5. Scotch Thistle

    Saundry on AW tracks

    Another consideration is that if an abandonment is made in good time for a shift to another venue on the same raceday, the club needing to shift might not want to move to the closest all weather track. For example, if the New Plymouth track was unusable, there are 4 tracks on which galloping meetings are held closer than Awapuni/Woodville (Hawera, Waverley, Wanganui and Stratford). The Taranaki JC and its sponsors, members, etc, and connections of acceptors, might prefer to race at one or any of them, rather than be dragooned off to Awapun/Woodville Think also of Wairoa being unable to race. They would logically prefer to move to Hastings or Gisborne, or maybe Waipukurau. At least in those instance all of the tracks mentioned race the same way round, left-handed. In the north, unless the all weather track is able to be used in either direction (with moveable finishing post, judge's box, etc?) there will be owners and trainers unwilling to race horses the opposite way round to the cancelled meeting. All and Saundry might have answers to such considerations, of course. One might be that by the time anything worthwhile gets done things will be so dire that most clubs will have folded.
  6. Scotch Thistle

    Saundry on AW tracks

    I can't see it happening either, not successfully anyway. Talk is cheap.
  7. Scotch Thistle

    Saundry on AW tracks

    There might be no mention of AWT/synthetic tracks in the NZF racing policy, but what matters more is what was signed up to post-election by the 3 coalition partners. And what has been wrangled since. At Karaka in January Peters said ..." Abandoned races result in millions of dollars lost to the racing industry each year. A further priority for this government is investment in an all-weather race track. This will be subject to this year’s government budget process. The objective is clear. Such a track would be an important step in helping certainty and consistency of racing." Although Peters referred to "an" and "a" (i.e.one) all-weather track, within days John Allen was referring to synthetic tracks and calling for 2 synthetic tracks, each costing $6-10 million, to be located at Cambridge and in Canterbury. Whether or not things add up depends on what items are being summed, and by whom? The way Peters operates I guess he is delighted that people are thrashing around in confusion, and I doubt that either of the other coalition partners cares at all (any more than the last government did).
  8. Scotch Thistle

    This is getting ridiculous....

    I'm not sure what to make of the prize money being headlined as "of $100,000" when it is actually of $98,000. I've nothing against the Equine Welfare Fund and the Jockey Welfare Fund sharing the other $2,000, but that money is not stakes money, it is a compulsory donation from connections. The $10,000,000 prize pool in the 2017 The Everest included a prize of $100,000 for the Equine Welfare Fund but nothing for the Jockey Welfare Fund. Maybe it is the Jockey Welfare Fund's turn in 2018; if so they will do better, given the total prize pool is $13,000,000 this year
  9. Scotch Thistle

    Charlie Studd

    Amazing that he defended the charge. Provides an insight into his character?
  10. Scotch Thistle

    Well Done Hawkes Bay Racing

    The Hawkes Bay Racing website tells us: Presumably blind eyes will be turned if a flask or two of brandy or rum are brought along. Or a keg of whisky if the Minister of Racing turns up with his friends and family in tow.
  11. Scotch Thistle

    Where do jockeys' costs fall?

    A couple of days ago I read that Jonathan Parkes is to ride Hiflyer when it races soon in Sydney, rather than a local jockey. This got me wondering in general terms who coughs up for the expenses of NZ jockeys engaged for long distance meetings. Apart from the mandatory riding fee, and the stakes percentage (if any), is it the case that deals are negotiated ride by ride by jockeys' agents? Is there a general pattern? I suppose any NZ jockey would happily meet their own costs to ride the rank outsider in the Melbourne Cup. I doubt any sought after northern jockey would pay their way for a ride at Waterlea or Washdyke.
  12. Scotch Thistle

    great racecallers

    Syd Tonks and Keith Haub for me. Of today's lot, Bruce Sherwin and Mark McNamara.
  13. Scotch Thistle

    And this bloke will save the Industry.....???

    It might help if the distinctions between the different components of the racing industry were clearer to the road worker. So too the differences between the financial returns to the top players in each component compared to those of the average and the strugglers. NZTR might be expected to promote understanding of the state of the NZ industry on behalf of those battling to continue participating in it. It is galling when NZTR's Racing Desk runs an article about Rachel Frost relocating to Victoria with a string of horses but doesn't report why she gave up on NZ (Racecafers know, but the average newspaper reader probably wonders given that Winston is supposedly throwing money at the industry).
  14. Scotch Thistle

    Get that humble pie warmed up ......

    I wonder whether the superannuation fraudster has wrangled a deal to suck the teat of the billion dollar slush fund for development assistance to the regions an all weather track or two, and perhaps other racing infrastructure
  15. Scotch Thistle

    Interesting Messara report

    Reading the article I was struck that there could be substance in some aspects of it, but also that De Lore is off beam, indeed comprehensively ignorant, on some matters he covers. An example is that he says ... Tabcorp must be favoured over the corporate bookmakers, as the organisation has a vested interest in racing as opposed to the corporates who exist primarily to return a profit to their shareholders ... when anyone with half a brain knows that Tabcorp is as corporate as it gets, being listed on the Australian Stock Exchange!